Beauty DIY Recipes · Wellness Travel · Maui Spas

A Maui Beauty Blog

Navigating beauty choices: What’s best animal, synthetic, or vegan beauty products?

synthetic vs vegan vs animal beauty products

In the ever-evolving world of beauty, we all face an array of choices regarding the ingredients in our skincare and cosmetics. 

No matter the origin, each type of product comes with its unique set of advantages and drawbacks.

Let’s delve into pros and cons to help you make informed decisions about what you put on your skin.

Animal-Derived Beauty Products

silk cocoons for beauty products


Proven Efficacy: They have a long history of use and are well-known for their effectiveness. Ingredients like lanolin (from sheep’s wool) and honey, for example, are praised for their moisturizing and antibacterial properties, respectively.

Cultural Significance: Respect and preserve the heritage and wisdom of cultures that have relied on these ingredients for centuries, maintaining traditional beauty practices and rituals. For example, see this blog post about Traditional Animal Beauty Products From Japan.


Ethical Concerns: The sourcing of animal-derived ingredients often raises questions about animal welfare.

Allergenic Potential: Ingredients such as bee pollen or lanolin are known allergens and can cause reactions in sensitive individuals.

Synthetic Beauty Products

synthetic beauty products


Consistency and Stability: Created to offer stability in beauty formulations, ensuring a longer shelf life and uniform performance across products.

Targeted Effectiveness: Designed and refined to perform specific functions that may not naturally occur in nature.

This allows for the creation of ingredients that address very specific skin concerns, such as improving skin elasticity, reducing the appearance of wrinkles, or even offering customized pigment colors that are consistent and vibrant. CoQ10 is an example of this.


Health Concerns: Ongoing concerns about the long-term health impacts of synthetic chemicals, including potential hormone disruptors and the presence of microplastics.

Our understanding of the effects of many synthetic chemicals is still developing, adding a layer of uncertainty about their safety.

Lack of Familiarity and Transparency: Complex chemical names are difficult to recognize and understand, which makes it challenging for consumers to identify what they are applying to their skin.

Vegan Beauty Products

linden flowers vegan beauty products


Cruelty-Free: Do not involve animals in their production, making them an ethical choice for those concerned about animal welfare.

Environmental Sustainability: Often, vegan products emphasize sustainability, with brands focusing on reducing environmental impact through eco-friendly packaging and sourcing.

However, sometimes the use of more plant materials may actually impact the environment negatively, through farming monocultures and deforestation.


Limiting Ingredient Choices: By cutting out whole groups of ingredients, vegan options may limit the effectiveness of certain types of beauty products.

Loss of Cultural Wisdom: A disconnection from the traditional knowledge and practices of many cultures that valued animal ingredients for their beauty and health benefits.


Choosing between animal, synthetic, and vegan beauty products involves weighing complex factors including effectiveness, ethics, cultural heritage, and environmental impact.

Each category has its strengths and drawbacks, reflecting the diversity of consumer values and needs.

As the beauty industry evolves, it continues to innovate, striving to blend the best of these worlds and minimize their limitations.

Understanding these pros and cons can help you make choices that align not just with your skincare needs but also with your ethical and cultural values.

Your Choice: The Benefit of DIY Beauty Products

The reason I love making my own beauty products is that you know exactly what goes into them.

You have the ultimate control over what goes onto your skin, allowing you to handpick every ingredient.

This personalized approach lets you decide whether to incorporate synthetics for their precision and effectiveness, animal-derived ingredients for their rich, traditional benefits, or to stick to purely vegan components for their natural and ethical qualities.

You can tailor your skincare to perfectly suit your needs and values.


Check out these popular beauty recipes & wellness blog posts:

Animal-Derived Beauty Products Form Japan

DIY Lavender Vanilla Body Oil

> DIY Lavender Milk Bath With Ali’i Kula Lavender

If you love natural skincare, wellness, Hawaii, and international beauty rituals, then sign up for my newsletter where I explore and test different beauty and wellness rituals from around the world. 

Leiohu Cosmetics owner Emma

Animal vs Synthetic vs Vegan Beauty Products


Book Now

Experience the transformative power of Hawaii's natural botanical ingredients and harness the healing energy of the islands at our DIY cosmetics workshops, where you create your own personalized beauty products.

Reserve your spot today and embark on a fun, rejuvenating journey of self-care and holistic wellness.